PIXEL - A Pixel Art Documentary


icon

Check out this short documentary about pixel art by animator Simon Cottee; in his own words it explores "the merits and impact of pixel art, animation and chiptune music". It contains a few interviews as well as showcasing snippets of several pixel art games and videos.


Posted by skamocore @ 5/25/2010 21:52  |    23

Discussion

If you would like to comment you will need to be logged in. Register now. It only takes a moment and it's free.


user
Metaru (Level 8 Brigadier General) @ 5/29/2010 19:55

holy butthurts batman


user
jalonso (Level 11 Godfather) @ 5/29/2010 19:27

Generally speaking documentaries are best when they generate conversations and further discussions beyond those presented by the filmaker. We are a community of pixelartists and surely documentaries like these will split us in our take on things. It doesn't take away from a fine job done on this film.

We posted this film as a news item for discussion. We found the video worthwhile, its well made.


user
lavalevel (Level 1 Rookie) @ 5/29/2010 16:27

Broad success is very relevant. If a majority of people really enjoyed it then that's great. Nothing comes without critics. It is perhaps stupid of me to engage them.

Metaru - Joe Brumm is a pixel artist and a great animator. I think Jason Rohrer uses the pixel style in a really interesting minimalist way, his name also has plenty of sway and benefited my video greatly. I've made 2 pixel animations myself:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Czf4nvI-jTQ
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZtIrk_-Vi50

Surely one of us can bring something to the table?

I tried to get in contact with SuperBrothers and Paul Robertson but they never responded. I wanted to speak to people who have really established themselves in the greater public eye. You say it isn't about elitism and that I should have contacted a "pixel artist." Do you mean a REAL one? Not one of these phoney ones I talked to who hardly qualify. A pixel artist like... yourself?

Anyway I'm now going to stop justifying anything, I don't need to. I shouldn't have to. My idea of pixel art goes further than people making anime style game sprites.

I know you feel you are authorities on pixel art, which is great. Go do something productive with it.


user
Adarias (Level 11 Special Agent) @ 5/29/2010 09:49

There nothing elitist happening here, all of this is done openly and on invitation.  Nobody here has said there's a right way to do things.  What people have attmepted to explain is that the documentary presents a rapid overview of a trend which is about 5% of the story, and calls this a summary of the whole (while also presenting some bogus information).

Nobody has suggested that your take on pixel art is wrong for a tiny fraction of the practitioners, only that it's infintesimally small compared to the whole body of work.  If there's an issue to take, it's that you haven't introduced anyone to the medium, you've introduced people to their own nostalgia, which is a valid yet separate phenomenon that belongs in a video with ninja turtles and voltron, but says little about an art form.  Minimalist furiture and design had a small nostalgic resurgence in the late 60's and early 70's, but talking about that doesn't mean we've actually discussed minimalism.  We're inviting you to explore the other 95% of pixel-art.

There's no bitterness here except what your injured pride might bring to the situation.  Try not taking the worst possible interpretation of everything your told.  And save the words about credentials or "broad" success - it's irrelevant to content or goals.


user
r1k (Level 1 Rookie) @ 5/29/2010 06:32

"I didn't realise the "pixel" scene was so exclusive and elite. I'm only a dabbler in the aesthetic, it has a simple pleasant allure to me. . You wanted it portrayed in your exact opinions and thoughts"

I think its not so much that we wanted our exact opinions to be portrayed, its just that you missed a big part of the pixel art scene, you only showed a small part of it.  I realize you were limited to 10 minutes on youtube so I wasnt expecting you to talk about everything, but still.  Anyways we shouldnt act like this was supposed to be some definitive film on pixel art, it just happened to be posted here.


user
Metaru (Level 8 Brigadier General) @ 5/29/2010 02:26

i dont believe it has nothing to do with elitism. its just, if you make something about pixel art, why not contact a pixel artist?

its not like if you put "pixel art" on google magically pixeljoint is one of the first results you get.


user
lavalevel (Level 1 Rookie) @ 5/29/2010 01:16

Hey Guys, Simon Cottee here. (I made this)

I think perhaps you are expecting too much from this. For starters I'm a uni student and it was just made for a class, the people I interviewed I had been in contact with personally so it was convenient. I had 11 minutes to work with under youtube constraints. It was my own opinions and look at pixel art, it was made for a broader audience and done with completely no budget by me in the middle of crazy assessment time over 2 days. That's not a justification of failure, I do think this documentary is of some quality and a valid good look at the medium.

I didn't realise the "pixel" scene was so exclusive and elite. I'm only a dabbler in the aesthetic, it has a simple pleasant allure to me. . You wanted it portrayed in your exact opinions and thoughts, all I can suggest is that you need to get together and make a truer documentary for yourselves. I don't know why people in the pixel scene have to act so "official" over it. Like I have committed some great pixel slander. 95% of people seemed ot really enjoy it, but some hardcore pixel guys had a great issue. I guess any level of broad success comes with critics. I did make it to get a closer look at your crafts, to raise some level of awareness for the medium, yet many of you just seem angered by any portrayal or attention.

I'm sure this will be a very inflammatory post. I just wanted to make contact and would love to iron any bitterness out (ironically I'm sure I'm creating much more).

Frost I would love to know your reasons behind your love for Pixel Art beyond what you have said. I think your work is great. I do find it hard to imagine anyone getting heavily into pixel art who doesn't also have a love for it's roots. If you don't want to have any level of nostalgia with your work, why use pixels over clean lines? - Hope this isn't read as aggressive.


user
Metaru (Level 8 Brigadier General) @ 5/27/2010 17:43

i'd like to know why too onek. because this whole documentary leaves me such a bitter taste of the whole "pixelated trend" that we already saw in fashion and such in a previous article.

what throws me off the most is that is a documentary about pixel art that interviews a game developer, a chiptune music composer, but there is no interview with any pixel artist, at all.


user
Adarias (Level 11 Special Agent) @ 5/27/2010 14:53

Well I tried leaving the creator a note so that he could be helped to see what was missing...

...but it looks like I might have slipped up...

...Someone with a stronger command of language and tone might want to help straighten this out; it appears I've come across as hauty and pretentious when I meant to be inviting.  Self-fail.


user
Frost (Level 6 Serial Killer) @ 5/27/2010 06:40

onek: Why?


user
onek (Level 6 Hitman) @ 5/27/2010 05:40

hmm.... i honestly start doubting in this community here ......   


user
Frost (Level 6 Serial Killer) @ 5/26/2010 22:36

I didn't like this at all. Almost nothing he said in this "documentary" appealed to me. I don't make "pixel art" to make it look more "pixel" than "art". I'm trying to make "art" with pixels, not the other way around. I like when things look smooth and nice, not all jagged and blocky.

As said before, this "documentary" only focus on one aspect of pixelart and that makes me think that he believes it is the only kind, and purpose, of pixelart. Nostalgia and blocky figures... I have never liked nostalgia and blocky pictures, not even as some kind of abstract art. What I like is pushing limitations on old hardware to make things that look good and beyond those limits. That is also one aspect of the demoscene; to push limits.

 


user
manxana (Level 2 Quiet One) @ 5/26/2010 19:33

we should make a documentary about pixel art


user
Metaru (Level 8 Brigadier General) @ 5/26/2010 19:13

all in all, all i could get from this is that pixel art is an iconic-driven expresion that is somehow fueled by the load of nostalgia it carries naturally on it.

but to be honest, it is quite forgetable... its not like it tries to explain the evolution of pixel art as an art medium, or actually explain the impact in pop culture(it just mentions that pixel art/chiptunes have been used in pop culture/music), but it just... hangs from the whole nostalgia that blocky mashups generate in people with 20~25+ years.

also this is purely personal but, it was that hard to have some close caption? half of the time i couldn't understand what the hell he was talking about.


user
r1k (Level 1 Rookie) @ 5/26/2010 19:09

It was okay, but as blueberry pie said, he seemed to only really focus on one type of pixel art.  the old retro, low res nes type stuff.  It kind of made it seem like pixel art is only good for that type of stuff which isnt true at all, he should have showed some of the other more illustrative stuff as well such as the kind of stuff Fool, or a bunch of other people here make.  I was also hoping he would talk more about pixel art on older computers like c64 and stuff like that and demo scene artists and stuff like that cause I dont really know anything about that scene but it seems pretty interesting.

He had some points like how alot of nes games you had to use youre imagination more, which is one reason I like those old game, but ya I never really thought the graphics on those old games looked like indecernable blobs, he was kind of exagerating there.

I should have been longer and he should have interviewed more people, but it was okay for what it was.


user
Adarias (Level 11 Special Agent) @ 5/26/2010 18:49

I feel like the guy talking about how we couldn't see pixels or discern characters way back when because of crappy screens should stick to saying things that are true. There's a reason we as kids sat close to the screen, but the fact was that most consols had pretty clear picture and there were a lot of early games and pixel art for computers as well.  He doesn't understand, appreciate, or possibly just doesn't remember old games, and should not have been interviewed on that subject.  He also sounded like a general dumbass with a lot of what he was saying, particularly with the idea "3d graphics are just a fad" and saying that people who impressed by the environment rendering and design in AC2 (which is a stunning achievement and is definitely a future of games) "aren't really literate in pixel-art" just makes him sound like a shitprick (not helped by his saying "renaissance architecture or whatever it is").  His "look at me being indy" photo bit was beyond pretentious too.

 

The second and third guys were much better.  it would have been nice to see them do some research and pull out older, good-looking games, as well as contemporary examples of brilliant work, or at least mention the super-crisp handheld/mobile platforms, but as a drive-by introduction, two-thirds of it was fine quality.


user
Chibi Robo (Level 5 Detective) @ 5/26/2010 18:28

I found the video to be really informative how pixel art has somewhat evolved into these crisp 3d graphic games, though most people neglect what the pixel really is.


user
Rostii (Level 3 Corporate Drone) @ 5/26/2010 16:51

 

 

It was an awesome video but he mainly spoke about the old pixelated games. Whenever i think of drawing like that it makes me sad. :L


user
0xDB (Level 5 Killer Klown) @ 5/26/2010 11:58

I found it boring to watch and had to force myself through it. I want those 11 minutes of my life back.


user
Badassbill (Level 11 Psychopath) @ 5/26/2010 04:39

This was fantastic. I hope this guy does more in the future.


user
Blueberry_pie (Level 7 General Manager) @ 5/26/2010 03:01

I don't know. It started out pretty good but after a minute or so it seemed to focus entirely on the whole retro/nostalgia thing. There's more to pixel art than that.


user
jeremy (Level 11 Special Agent) @ 5/25/2010 23:39

 Very nice


user
jalonso (Level 11 Godfather) @ 5/25/2010 22:16

A must watch for all PJ members.


This Week's Pixel Art

Olly Steele icon/pixelartback of a robot icon/pixelartLittle MockUp icon/pixelartPractice portrait icon/pixelart
Play party games with QuizBash app
Play party games with QuizBash app

Recent News

Donate

Want to give some dough back to all those amazing pixel artists? Donations provide prize money for contests, help cover hosting costs and support new initiatives.